Just when you thought all was lost, and there were no good ideas anymore (unless you've been reading the Global Ideas Bank, of course)....here comes the Sunday Times to save us with its Brainstorm to rescue Britain. To quote from the article:
"New ideas. Fresh thinking. Action. That's what Britain needs but traditional politicians seem unable to deliver. So what do people who actually run the country - the leaders in business, arts, science and other fields - suggest? To find out The Sunday Times has put together a panel of top achievers, unfettered by party politics, to examine how to improve Britain"
I'm all in favour of this: new ideas, fresh thinking...all sounds good to me. And some of the suggestions from their first survey of the panel seem eminently sensible, and refreshingly robust. They also cover, amongst the 250 of them, a wide-range of fields in business, the arts, the public sector and so on.
This weekend, though, I was also reading the book Ideas Are Free by Alan Robinson and Dean Schroeder. It is primarily concerned with how ideas can liberate organisations, but they also make some important, if obvious points about the world we live in today. Namely that the old idea that managers 'think' and employees 'do' is dated and irrelevant in today's world. Many of the best ideas, the most radical thinking, comes from those on the shop floor who experience the problems (or see the opportunities) day-to-day.
So why should it be any different when it comes to politics? Why, when creating a think-tank as a counter to politicians, is it dominated by "the people who actually run the country"? Why do chairmen and chief executives have fresher thinking and new ideas than the people who work for them, or the people they provide a service to? Whilst these high achievers clearly do have expertise and knowledge, could the Sunday Times not also have a think-tank alongside made up of 250 people from the organisations that are represented on the panel? The security guard from the British Museum as well as the Deputy Director; a student from the University of Essex as well as the Vice Chancellor; a mobile phone salesmen as well as John Caudwell; a fireman as well as Andy Gilchrist....and so on. These are the people who actually run the country, and they may have a much clearer idea of the problems than any number of high-flyers.